Introduction
Testicular torsion is a time-sensitive urological emergency caused by twisting of spermatic cords that compromises blood flow to testicles. If testicular torsion is not treated promptly, it can lead to ischemic injury. Early surgical interventions are critical in salvaging affected testes.1,2 The global incidence of testicular torsion ranges from 2 to 27 cases per 100,000 individuals among males younger than 25 years, with the incidence peaking in adolescence.3–5 Time from symptom onset to detorsion is the principal factor determining testicular salvageability. Testicular salvageability is highest if detorsion is performed within first 6 hours.4,6,7 Delays in detorsion significantly reduce the salvageability rate.4,8–10
The outcomes of testicular torsion vary across countries. In low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), outcomes are worse than in high income settings due to delayed seeking of care, limited specialist availability, and delays in surgical interventions.11,12 In 2023, a scoping review from sub-Saharan Africa including 1,410 patients reported a mean symptom-onset-to-consultation interval of 52.5 hours and a mean orchiectomy rate of 46.4% (range 13.2%–72%).13–16 The orchiectomy rates were higher in studies reporting prior referral to another health center and in studies reporting ultrasound use.13 Rwanda was not represented among the studies included in the scoping review. Thus, it is essential to examine urgent interventions to reduce orchiectomy rates in low-resource settings.1,16
To our knowledge, no previous study has specifically reported testicular torsion outcomes in Rwanda. Therefore, we conducted this study at a tertiary referral hospital in southern Rwanda to determine the hospital-based prevalence of testicular torsion among urology admissions, to describe the clinical profile of affected patients, and to identify factors associated with orchiectomy during the index admission.
Methods
Study design and setting
This retrospective, hospital-based, cross-sectional study was conducted in the urology department of a university teaching hospital in Southern Province, Rwanda. The study period was conducted from January 1, 2018, to December 31, 2023.
Study population and eligibility criteria
This study included all male patients with testicular torsion who were admitted between January 1, 2018, and December 31, 2023. Eligible cases were identified from archived patient files, admission registers, theatre records and OpenClinic (electronic medical records) using free text and ICD-10 diagnostic terms related to testicular torsion and acute scrotum. The exclusion criteria were as follows: a diagnosis of testicular torsion was ruled out based on clinical assessment or surgical findings; or incomplete medical records that lacked essential information.
A total of 8806 cases of testicular torsion were managed in the urology department during the study period. A total of 129 potentially eligible records were screened; 21 were excluded because torsion was ruled out, and 5 were excluded because essential data were missing from the medical record. Ultimately, 103 cases were included for analysis.
Variables and definitions
Data were extracted into a spreadsheet using a standardized data collection tool. The following variables were extracted: age (<20 years, 20–30 years and >30 years), province of origin, means of arrival (direct presentation vs transfer), time from symptom onset to diagnosis (<6 hours, 6–12 hours, 12–24 hours, >24 hours), Doppler ultrasonography, arterial blood-flow findings, time from hospital arrival to initiation of management (<6 hours, 6–12 hours, >12 hours), procedure performed, and surgical outcome.
Diagnosis was defined as the first documented clinician-derived diagnosis of testicular torsion. Management initiation was defined as time the patient was taken to the operating room. Exact times to scrotal exploration and detorsion were not available for all included cases.
Outcome measures and statistical analysis
The primary outcome was orchiectomy during index admission. Testis-preserving surgical management was defined as detorsion via orchidopexy, manual detorsion followed by surgical fixation, or non-surgical conservative management. Descriptive analysis was conducted to summarize patient characteristics. The hospital-based prevalence of testicular torsion was calculated as the number of torsion cases divided by the total number of urology cases during the study period.
For inferential analysis, orchiectomy was coded as the binary outcome (performed vs not performed). Univariate logistic regression was used to assess the associations between potential predictors and orchiectomy. Microsoft Excel was used for data cleaning and coding; IBM SPSS Statistics 27 was used for both descriptive and inferential analyses. To select variables for inclusion in the binary logistic regression model, χ2 tests were performed to assess the associations between testicular salvageability and potential predictor variables with significant correlations (P value <0.05) and age. The potential predictors were identified based on a literature review. A reduced multivariate logistic regression was then fit using clinically relevant variables with adequate empirical support: age group, symptom onset-to-diagnosis time (<12 hours vs ≥12 hours), and time from arrival to management (≤12 hours vs >12 hours). Results were reported as odds ratios (ORs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). P values <0.05 indicated statistical significance.
Ethical considerations
Ethical approval was obtained from Institutional Review Board of the University Teaching Hospital of Butare (approval number REC/UTHB/074/2023). Permission to access hospital records was also granted by the University Teaching Hospital of Butare. The data were anonymized before analysis.
Results
During the study period, 103 patients with testicular torsion were identified among 8806 urology admissions, yielding a hospital-based prevalence of 1.17%. The mean age was 21.56 (SD 8.49) years, the median age was 20 (IQR 16–22.5) years, and the range was 11 to 57 years. Fifty (48.5%) patients were aged younger than 20 years, 37 (35.9%) were aged 20–30 years, and 16 (15.5%) were aged older than 30 years (Table 1). Most patients (87/103, 84.5%) originated from Southern Province, and 99 (96.1%) were transferred from another facility.
Only 3 (2.9%) patients were diagnosed within 6 hours of symptom onset; 31 (30.1%) patients were diagnosed between 6–12 hours after symptom onset; 30 (29.1%) patients were diagnosed between at 12–24 hours after onset; and 39 (37.9%) patients were diagnosed more than 24 hours after symptom onset. These categories represent recorded diagnosis intervals rather than time to exploration or detorsion.
Doppler ultrasonography was performed in 96 (93.2%) patients, while 7 (6.8%) patients did not undergo Doppler ultrasonography. Among the imaged patients, absent arterial blood flow was documented in 73 (76.0%) patients, decreased flow was observed in 19 (19.8%) patients, and a normal or increased flow was seen in 4 (4.2%) patients.
The dataset did not include the times at which Doppler ultrasonography was requested, performed or reported. Furthermore, the dataset did not include typical ultrasound turnaround times at referring facilities. Therefore, delays attributable to ultrasound could not be quantified.
Six (5.8%) patients started symptom management within 6 hours of hospital arrival; , 57 (55.3%) patients started management between 6 and 12 hours after hospital arrival; and 40 (38.8%) patients started management more than 12 hours after hospital arrival. Surgical exploration was the most common management strategy. Orchiectomy was performed in 73 (70.9%) patients. Of the 30 (29.1%) patients who did not undergo orchiectomy, 29 underwent testis-preserving surgery, while 1 was managed conservatively. Contralateral orchidopexy was performed in 100 (98.0%) of the 102 patients who underwent surgical management. Table 1 illustrates the sociodemographic characteristics of the study.
Testis-preserving management strategies varied markedly across clinically important subgroups, as shown in Table 2. Avoidance of orchiectomy was documented in 24 (70.6%) of the 34 patients diagnosed within 12 hours of symptom onset compared with only 6 (8.7%) of the 69 patients diagnosed at or after 12 hours of symptom onset. Salvage was recorded for 28 (44.4%) of 63 patients whose management started within 12 hours of hospital arrival compared with 2 (5.0%) of 40 patients whose management started at or after 12 hours post-hospital arrival. Among the 73 patients whose Doppler ultrasonography results revealed a lack of arterial blood flow, 67 underwent orchiectomy, and 6 underwent testis-preserving surgery. None of the 23 patients whose Doppler ultrasonography results revealed the presence of arterial blood flow underwent orchiectomy. Among the 7 patients who did not undergo Doppler ultrasonography, 6 underwent orchiectomy, while 1 was managed conservatively
In unadjusted analyses, recorded diagnosis within 12 hours and recorded management initiation within 12 hours were associated with lower odds of orchiectomy (Table 3). In the reduced multivariable model, recorded diagnosis within 12 hours remained independently associated with lower odds of orchiectomy (adjusted OR [aOR] 0.08, 95% CI 0.02–0.25; P <0.001). No statistically significant independent association was detected between recorded management initiation within 12 hours and orchiectomy (aOR 0.19, 95% CI 0.04–1.02; P = 0.053). Age was not independently associated with the odds of orchiectomy.
Discussion
This study revealed that testicular torsion accounted for 1.17% of urology admissions at a tertiary referral hospital in Rwanda, but the burden of adverse in-hospital outcomes was impactful. Approximately 75% of the included patients underwent orchiectomy. Because postoperative viability and atrophy were not assessed, the 29 testis-preserving procedures documented in this dataset should not be interpreted as confirmed long-term testicular salvage. Most patients were adolescents and young adults, which is consistent with the previously established age distribution of testicular torsion.4,9,13,15
A recorded diagnosis within 12 hours of symptom onset was associated with substantially lower odds of orchiectomy. This association remained significant even after adjusting for age and in-hospital delay. These findings are physiologically plausible and align with previous literature showing that testicular viability declines rapidly as ischemia time increases.2,10,15,17 Nevertheless, this study did not measure the exact time to exploration or detorsion; thus, the association should not be interpreted as a direct estimate of the effect of ischemia duration.
Most patients were transferred from another facility, suggesting that referral and interfacility processes may contribute to prolonged recorded intervals. However, the available data could not separate patient delays, first-facility delay, transfer time and in-hospital delay. Delays may occur before patients reach a facility that is capable of surgical exploration. Alternatively, delays may occur after arrival while diagnostic imaging, specialist review, and access to operating rooms are being arranged. In our cohort, more than 33% of patients waited longer than 12 hours after hospital arrival to receive initial management, highlighting an additional opportunity for quality improvement.13–16
Among patients who underwent Doppler ultrasonography, a lack of arterial blood flow was associated with higher odds of orchiectomy. However, none of the patients with arterial blood flow underwent orchiectomy. This “zero cell” in the dataset prevented stable estimation with standard logistic regression. However, because torsion is a time-critical surgical emergency primarily diagnosed based on clinical presentation, ultrasound should not delay management when clinical suspicion is high. Doppler ultrasonography may assist with uncertain diagnoses.
The near-universal use of contralateral fixation in this cohort reflects appropriate preventive practice during surgical exploration.1,2,18 Compared with the mean orchiectomy rate of 46.4% reported in the scoping review of sub-Saharan African countries, the rate of 70.9% observed herein was higher and near the upper end of the scoping review’s range (13.2%–72%). The scoping review also found a higher rate of orchiectomy in studies reporting prior referral to another health center (52.4% vs 36.9% in studies not reporting referral). The very high transfer proportion (96.1%), referral-hospital case selection, prolonged recorded diagnosis intervals and possible differences in access to specialist and theater services may partly explain the difference. Rwanda was not represented in the scoping review, and heterogeneous definitions and reporting practices prevent reliable comparisons against individual neighboring countries.13
This study has several limitations. Its retrospective design introduced reliance on the completeness and accuracy of routine clinical documentation. The exact times of hospital arrival, scrotal exploration and detorsion were unavailable, and the operational timing variables may have been misclassified. Prehospital delay could not be separated into patient, first-facility and transport components. Sparse and zero cells in the dataset limited model stability and the number of variables that could be used for model adjustment. Long-term postoperative viability, atrophy and endocrine or fertility outcomes were not available. Finally, this dataset from a single referral hospital may not represent other facilities or the population incidence of testicular torsion in Rwanda.
Nevertheless, this study provides local, hospital-based evidence and identifies potential system-level strategies. These strategies include public and clinician education, rapid referral pathways, immediate theater prioritization. Furthermore, general surgeons and clinicians at district and regional hospitals should be trained regarding the prompt assessment and emergency management of torsion, including scrotal exploration, detorsion, orchidopexy and orchiectomy, rather than relying exclusively on urologists at tertiary centers.
Future work should include a multicenter Rwandan study involving district-level, regional and tertiary hospitals to characterize national hospital-based patterns. A prospective pathway study should be conducted to record exact times of symptom onset, first presentation, referral decision, departure, ultrasound request and completion, arrival at the definitive hospital, surgical decision, exploration and detorsion. Follow-up assessments should include measurements of Doppler perfusion, testicular volume and atrophy after testis-preserving surgery.
Conclusion
Testicular torsion accounted for a low proportion of urology cases at a tertiary referral hospital in Rwanda, but there a high rate of orchiectomy was observed. A shorter recorded interval from symptom onset to diagnosis was independently associated with lower odds of orchiectomy. The time between arrival and management initiation was not independently associated with the odds of orchiectomy. Because exact times to surgical exploration and detorsion were unavailable, the current findings should not be interpreted as estimates of total ischemia time or time to surgery. Prospective evaluations of patient, referral and in-hospital intervals are needed to identify modifiable sources of delay.
Acknowledgments
We thank the University Teaching Hospital of Butare staff for facilitating access to records and supporting data collection. We also acknowledge guidance of the supervisory team.
Ethical Approval
Ethical approval was obtained from the University Teaching Hospital of Butare Institutional Review Board (REC/UTHB/074/2023). The University Teaching Hospital of Butare also granted permission to access patient records. All personally identifiable data were anonymized before analysis.
Informed Consent
Due to the retrospective nature of the study, Informed consent was waived by the CHUB Institutional Review Board. All data collected were solely used for research purpose only.
Data Availability
The study’s dataset is available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request, subject to ethical approval and confidentiality requirements.
Conflict of interest
None
Funding
None
AI Assistance declaration
Grammarly version 1.2.277.1921 was used to correct grammar and to structure the sentences. This tool was not used to generate original scientific data, conduct independent scientific analyses or formulate scientific conclusions. The authors assume full responsibility and accountability for the entire content of this manuscript, including sections developed with the assistance of AI tools. Any AI outputs were thoroughly reviewed, verified and approved by the authors.